The bluest of peepers, framed in the tightest of closeups, can be found staring out at you from a movie screen. No, not Elizabeth Holmes’s in the hotly debated documentary “You Can See Everything,” though her eerily unblinking stare, somehow both insinuating and vacant, certainly runs a close second. I speak of Andrew Scott in the muddled biographical drama “Elsinore,” in which he plays the London-based Scottish actor Ian Charleson in the autumn of 1989, during some of the unbearable and extraordinary final months of his life. Ian, who’s forty, is living with AIDS in an era when the diagnosis is a death sentence, and he already has a ghostly white pallor that brings out the intensity of his eyes, which sparkle like deep-set sapphires. (Scott, whose eyes are brown, wore blue contact lenses during production.) His complexion also contrasts starkly with a lesion that appears, early in the film, near his right temple—one of many that will eventually cover his body, though it’s the only one that worries him for now. A skin growth on an arm or a leg can be covered, but a blotch on Ian’s face, even when obscured with makeup, might catch a viewer’s attention.
Ian is used to getting noticed on stage and off, though the source of such recognition can be exasperating. He’s best known for his performance as the Olympic-champion runner Eric Liddell in “Chariots of Fire” (1981), a film that is itself best known for a musical score that most would call iconic and Ian would term incessant. He can barely promote a new project on a talk show without being assaulted on the air by the composer Vangelis’s overweeningly cosmic synths; in a cab, he nods along indulgently as the driver hums the whole damn theme. Ian has resigned himself to the fact that “Chariots of Fire” will lead his obituaries, and also to the likelihood that those obituaries are not too far away. But then he learns that Daniel Day-Lewis, a star on the rise, has mysteriously dropped out of the role of Hamlet at the National Theatre—and the director, Richard Eyre (a fine Johnny Flynn), asks Ian to take over, mid-run. Famously, the production marked the last time that Day-Lewis ever appeared in a play; for infinitely sadder reasons, it also gave us the last role of Ian Charleson’s life. (He made it through twenty-four performances of “Hamlet” at the National and died weeks later, in January, 1990.)
“Elsinore,” directed by the Australian filmmaker Simon Stone and written by Stephen Beresford, seeks to make a heroic spectacle of Ian’s refusal to go gentle into that good night. He already lives, breathes, and often quotes “Hamlet”—he played the prince of Denmark before, in 1974, at a theatre in Cambridge—and he’s determined to summon every last reserve of his energy, which is waning, and his talent, which is considerable. He has the unflagging support of his closest friend, the casting director Patsy Pollock (Billie Piper), but also the stern disapproval of his doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), who knows that the stress of rehearsals and performances will only hasten Ian’s physical decline. Johnson is a real-life pioneer in H.I.V. and AIDS treatment, and Colman plays her with a bracing dash of vinegar; the pleasure of her scenes with Scott lies in the sugary grace notes that gradually seep into their interplay. Doctor and patient reach a respectful impasse when Margaret tells Ian that her priority is the preservation of life, to which Ian replies that life can also be measured in quality, not quantity.
This is a worthy sentiment, though I’m not sure that Stone, a more-is-more kind of filmmaker, grasps its value as an aesthetic principle. The movie is built around an almost mathematical sense of amplification—it’s a mortality-driven tearjerker and a testament to the power of art—and it mashes together Ian’s onstage triumphs and behind-the-scenes travails in a monotonous manner that eventually leeches both of meaning. The montages in “Elsinore” go on forever; more than once, I longed for Stone to slow down and let an extended scene of rehearsal play out—to have Ian puzzle over a particular line reading or a bit of blocking, unadorned by crosscutting or music. Instead, “Hamlet” is reduced to a collage of high-flown sound bites, interrupted and sometimes drowned out by fits of coughing and retching. The plague’s the thing.
A cynic might observe that, for an actor, the chance to declaim some of Shakespeare’s greatest lines and showily waste away from terminal illness amounts to two thespian challenges rolled into one—a kind of Oscar-qualifying biathlon. If so, no one could deny that Andrew Scott is in intensely competitive shape, and he grabs hold of you so thoroughly as to send your skepticism into retreat. The part calls for extremes of suffering and showmanship, but Scott finds room for modulation; his Ian retains two qualities—a core of tenderness, and a persistently impish wit—that somehow survive every setback that AIDS can hurl at them. Is it churlish to note that Scott was even better, and rather less effortful, in “All of Us Strangers” (2023), in which he brought a delicate, haunting interiority to the role of Adam, a lonely gay Londoner? Adam undergoes the quietest yet most transformative of spiritual and emotional journeys; he isn’t the same person at the beginning, the end, or, indeed, at any point in the movie. Ian, by contrast, is all dogged determination from start to finish. He flails, suffers, and ultimately transcends, but he doesn’t expand.
Ian’s one decisive shift concerns the matter of visibility: although he’s kept his sexuality private, he decides that, once he’s gone, the cause of his death will be made known. He arrives at this decision through a tense reckoning with the pioneering gay director Derek Jarman (David Dawson), who bitterly resents Ian for essentially disavowing their collaboration on the queer-punk film “Jubilee” (1978) and for suppressing his sexuality publicly in a bid for Hollywood acceptance. The film’s depiction of Charleson and Jarman’s spats, however rooted in truth, is corrected and diminished by Theo Rollason’s excellent recent documentary “Queer Edward II,” which features newly discovered archival footage from the set of “Edward II,” Jarman’s period drama from 1991. Like “Elsinore,” Rollason’s documentary—which premièred at the Venice and London film festivals and is still, as of this writing, seeking a U.S. distributor—addresses Jarman’s passionate commitment to art and activism, and also his controversial willingness to pressure closeted celebrities into outing themselves. Yet the real Jarman, even at his most confrontational, is shown to possess an infectious warmth, ebullience, and largeness of spirit—all of which render the glaring, vitriolic Jarman of “Elsinore” almost unrecognizable by comparison. Not for the first time in this movie, the truth seems to overwhelm the filmmaker’s imagination.
I invoked the Oscars flippantly, but not unreasonably. It’s hard to avoid the subject in the case of “Elsinore,” partly because the film has been widely tipped to earn Scott a nomination for Best Actor, but also because the legacy of the Academy Awards looms over the story itself: “Chariots of Fire” won Best Picture in 1982, a choice that hasn’t aged half as well as Vangelis’s score. By curious if just-short-of-fascinating coincidence, there’s a new film in theatres that unfolds under the shadow of another Oscar winner, “Rocky” (1976)—a better-regarded champ than “Chariots,” though it, too, features more than its fair share of musically charged sprinting. “I Play Rocky,” directed by Peter Farrelly from a screenplay by Peter Gamble, exalts the making of an improbable yet immortal American classic—and the birth of a movie star, Sylvester Stallone, played here by a charismatic and enormously likable young actor named Anthony Ippolito.
We encounter the young Stallone as a cash-strapped nobody in mid-nineteen-seventies New York City, working at a fishmonger’s, auditioning for nothing parts, and calling himself Mike. His deeply supportive girlfriend, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), encourages him to write his own scripts—and to go by Sylvester, a name that once made him a target of childhood bullies. Sylvester isn’t an obvious moniker for a working stiff with a wink-wink taste for raw eggs, but the incongruity is the point. This guy, who tries out for roles such as Thug No. 2 by day and recites Walt Whitman’s “I Sing the Body Electric” by night, has unexpected poetry in him, and it bursts forth in his stubborn desire to be an actor and a screenwriter. In time, he and Sasha marry and move to Los Angeles, where he charms and hustles his way into the offices of the producers Irwin Winkler (P. J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), a pair of savvy industry gatekeepers who, like most everyone else, feel dubious about Sylvester at first. By the film’s end, they will believe in him as passionately as he believes in himself.
“I Play Rocky” wants us to believe in Sylvester, too, which is easy enough to do. Ippolito, magnetizing the camera with a sleepy-eyed stare, and mumbling his lines with a deft approximation of Stallone’s slightly slurred delivery, is an astounding physical and verbal match for Stallone, and you can’t take your eyes off him—or close your ears to him—even when the movie pulls its narrative punches. Given what Stallone has revealed in interviews, some of them to promote his recent memoir, “The Steps,” the character’s home life feels patchy and sanitized. Gone is anything more than a hint of emotional turbulence between Sylvester and his father, Frank Stallone, Sr. (an almost unrecognizable Matt Dillon), who cruelly disparages his son at every turn.
Sylvester’s big eureka moment takes place in an L.A. bar, where he catches an epic fifteen-round boxing match between Muhammad Ali and Chuck Wepner—and then immediately races home to write “Rocky” in a three-and-half-day burst of inspiration. This backstory is the stuff of Hollywood legend, and “I Play Rocky” reprints it gleefully, with nary a concern that legend alone might not suffice. Sylvester, a movie nut, knows a thing or two about what makes a picture work, but where did he get his writerly instincts, his sense of narrative drive and structure? A title card from earlier in the film—“SIXTEEN MONTHS AND EIGHT SCREENPLAYS LATER . . .”—doesn’t exactly tell the story.
The best scenes in “I Play Rocky” arrive shortly after the script is written and triumphantly presented to Winkler and Chartoff—at which point Sylvester delivers the ultimatum of the title. Sandy Maddox (a rudely amusing Tracy Letts), an executive at United Artists (and a composite of several real-life individuals), wants a bankable star such as Robert Redford or Burt Reynolds, and the tug-of-war negotiations that ensue open up an engrossing, sharply satirical window onto the frivolity and arbitrariness that so often govern Hollywood. Farrelly and Gamble attempt a deeper process dive once the film is green-lit, though it’s here that “I Play Rocky” goes on making-of-“Rocky” autopilot, stuffed with reënactments of beloved scenes and recognizable setups. Here is Sylvester in gray sweats, lunging up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art, and there he goes, tottering after Talia Shire on an ice-skating rink—a scene that nearly gets axed at the last minute, against Sylvester’s protests. Here, too, is the film’s journeyman director, John G. Avildsen (Jay Duplass), who has a talent for passing off thrift as realism, and whose cost-cutting instinct threatens to derail Sylvester’s ambitions as often as it helps realize them. Those ambitions will pay off, of course, and how: the finished “Rocky” will bring audiences to their feet, become the highest-grossing film of 1976, and prove the smirking Sandy Maddoxes of the world wrong.
“I Play Rocky” isn’t just an underdog story; it’s practically an underdog shelter. Rocky Balboa is an underdog in the boxing ring, “Rocky” is an underdog at the box office and the Oscars, and Stallone is an underdog in Hollywood—and, in his case, an underdog with a literal underdog, an abandoned bullmastiff that he finds on the streets of New York and adopts as his own. No doubt Farrelly’s film fancies itself an underdog, too—a scrappy, feel-good David of a picture, going up against the industry’s many shiny prestige Goliaths, and seeking to honor an earlier tradition of nervy but popular American filmmaking. For all that, I’m not convinced the film entirely buys, or successfully sells, its own mythmaking. Again and again, Farrelly, who unwittingly revealed the toxic side of nostalgia in the slickly retrograde, Best Picture-winning “Green Book” (2018), sacrifices real suspense and drama on the altar of fan-service reënactment. Beat by beat, “I Play Rocky” leans so complacently on the audience’s assumed love and knowledge of “Rocky” that it defeats its own stakes. It takes the triumph of the underdog too easily for granted. ♦