Puccini’s breakneck tragedy has always been popular in New York: so much that you could hear two versions in 24 hours last weekend.
“Tosca” is probably the opera I’ve seen the most. It isn’t my favorite, but I never get tired of Puccini’s exquisitely lurid score: a riptide of music drama that grabs you by the heart for two pulse-pounding hours of passion, intrigue and tragedy.
I’m far from alone. “Tosca” first came to the United States in 1901, a year after its premiere, and has been an audience favorite ever since. It comes around often, and last weekend in Manhattan, it was even possible to see two versions of it within 24 hours: the New York Philharmonic’s concert performance at Carnegie Hall on Friday night, and the Metropolitan Opera’s latest revival, with the debut of a phenomenal soprano, on Saturday afternoon.
The Philharmonic’s “Tosca” was the start of a five-year project for the orchestra and Gustavo Dudamel, its new music and artistic director, to present operas in concert at Carnegie Hall. In future seasons, they should really think about what they can add to this city’s opera scene; “Tosca” is not an imaginative choice. (Somehow, last weekend was also the second time this year that the Philharmonic and the Met have programmed the same thing.)
It was nevertheless worth hearing how the Philharmonic performed “Tosca,” as if showing an X-ray of the score. Partly, this was an effect of taking the music out of the pit and onto the stage. But Dudamel’s interpretation also had a remarkable sense of detail. The opera opens with Puccini’s theme for the villainous Scarpia, a series of chords that land like hammer blows. At the end of Act II, when Tosca kills Scarpia, the theme returns as a ghostly shadow of itself, and in Dudamel’s reading it was a heavy vapor, suffocating as much as it haunted.
The opening of the third act was pleasantly shapeless, a collection of pastoral sounds and the clashing church bells of a Roman morning, leading to a moving cello solo that introduced the big aria “E lucevan le stelle.” It was a well-deserved spotlight for Matthew Christakos, who has been filling in and continuously impressing as the Philharmonic’s principal cellist since the retirement of Carter Brey last season.
We are having trouble retrieving the article content.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.
Thank you for your patience while we verify access.